Review: iMovie for iPhone 4

This won’t be a comprehensive review, because those exist elsewhere (best of breed here), but I have put this app through its paces and have a few points to make about it for those on the fence about whether to buy or not.

Things that annoy me:

  • Location services must be on to use the app. Why? You can geotag clips, but I don’t want to be FORCED to do so.
  • Only video clips shot with an iPhone can be used.
  • Added text lasts the entire length of the clip and takes up a big portion of the frame.
  • Audio can’t be moved at all, and when it ends, it ends.
  • You can trim video from both ends by using handles, but it’s difficult to see what you’re trimming (easier to trim and then import).

Things that I like:

  • It’s relatively easy to cute-ify video clips.
  • You don’t have to have a desktop computer to join clips on the fly.
  • You can pick what size to export, and it includes HD, which looks good (way to make use of the new iPhone 4 video-recording capabilities!).
  • You can add video and photos, and you can do the Ken Burns thing with photos. Result: quick-and-dirty video that looks pretty polished.

I spent a half hour messing with this software and slapped together a project of my trip to Italy (see on YouTube). Keep in mind this video was shot with a 3GS—not in HD).

Screenshots:

 

Ken Burns effect

Choosing image transitions

For $5 this is a fairly sophisticated app. For people who shoot a lot of video clips and like to share them, it’s probably a should-have (eg, people with kids or active blogs). For people who shoot longer videos or videos with multiple devices, it’s probably best to stick with a desktop video-editing software. Beyond a few minutes of editing, iMovie on the iPhone’s limitations just get too frustrating.

 

Posted by on Jul 12, 2010 in Blog, Product Reviews | Comments Off

Comments are closed.